Fluffernutter Pie Recipe

Imagine a world where your childhood sandwich gets transformed into a dreamy, creamy slice of dessert heaven—that’s exactly what happens with Fluffernutter Pie. This no-bake treat takes all the nostalgia of peanut butter and marshmallow, swirls it into a lush filling, and tucks it into a crispy graham cracker crust. It’s rich, fluffy, and unapologetically playful—a showstopper for family gatherings, potlucks, or anytime you want to indulge in something a little whimsical. Get ready to fall in love with every bite!

this Recipe

Ingredients You’ll Need

What makes this dessert truly shine is its lineup of familiar, easy-to-find ingredients. Each component is essential to achieving the signature taste and texture that make Fluffernutter Pie swoon-worthy—think nutty, silky, sweet, and delightfully light all at once!

• Prepared graham cracker crust: This classic crust is the crunchy foundation that holds together all the creamy sweetness.
• Creamy peanut butter: For that unmistakable nutty flavor and smooth texture—choose your favorite brand for best results.
• Cream cheese, softened (8 ounces): Adds tang and velvety richness to balance the sweet notes of the filling.
• Marshmallow creme (7 ounces): The star for extra fluff and nostalgic, gooey sweetness throughout.
• Whipped topping (8 ounces), plus extra for garnish: Folds seamlessly for an ultra-light, airy pie—don’t skip the extra dollop on top!
• Milk (2 tablespoons): Just enough to make the filling silky smooth and easy to spread.
• Chopped roasted peanuts (optional): For a salty crunch and a little flair when garnishing.

How to Make Fluffernutter Pie

Step 1: Creamy Peanut Butter & Cream Cheese Blend

Start by grabbing your largest mixing bowl—trust me, you’ll want room to whip everything together. Beat the softened cream cheese and creamy peanut butter until the mixture becomes silky smooth with no lumps. This creates that indulgent base and ensures every bite tastes perfectly blended, not streaky or grainy.

Step 2: Add the Sweetness

Next, spoon in all that dreamy marshmallow creme along with the milk. Keep mixing until everything melds into a unified, fluffy mixture. This step is what gives Fluffernutter Pie its signature airy texture and that sweet, unmistakable marshmallow flavor.

Step 3: Lighten with Whipped Topping

Gently fold in the whipped topping using a spatula, being careful not to deflate the mixture. The secret here is patience—take your time so the filling stays light and cloud-like. This will give your pie a gorgeous, mousse-like consistency.

Step 4: Fill the Crust

Spoon the filling into your prepared graham cracker crust. Smooth out the top with an offset spatula or the back of a spoon until it looks pillowy. Take a quiet moment to appreciate how luscious it already looks (and maybe sneak a taste—chef’s privilege!).

Step 5: Chill to Perfection

Pop the whole pie into your refrigerator and let it chill for at least 4 hours (overnight is even better). This crucial step helps the filling to set and become sliceable while the flavors meld beautifully.

Step 6: Garnish & Serve

Just before serving, crown your Fluffernutter Pie with extra whipped topping and a hearty sprinkle of chopped roasted peanuts. For extra wow, drizzle a little melted chocolate or peanut butter over the top. Slice, serve, and watch those smiles appear!

How to Serve Fluffernutter Pie

Garnishes

Garnishing this pie is the cherry-on-top of the Fluffernutter Pie experience! Swirl on a hefty cloud of whipped topping, scatter over some chopped roasted peanuts for crunch, and if you’re feeling fancy, zigzag a bit of warm peanut butter or chocolate sauce. These little finishing touches make your dessert downright irresistible.

Side Dishes

Since Fluffernutter Pie is rich and luscious, pair it with something cool and light. Think a mug of strong coffee, a glass of icy milk, or even a bright fruit salad to offset all that creamy decadence. If you’re serving at a party, fresh berries and a bowl of mixed nuts work beautifully, too!

Creative Ways to Present

Cut the pie into thick, generous wedges for classic appeal, or use a small round cutter for cute, bite-sized mini Fluffernutter Pies at your next gathering. You could even serve individual slices in pretty dessert glasses, layered with extra whipped topping and drizzled with chocolate or peanut butter—party-ready and stunning!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you find yourself with leftovers (a rarity, but miracles happen), simply cover the pie tightly with plastic wrap or aluminum foil and keep it in the refrigerator. It’ll stay fresh, creamy, and delicious for up to 3 days—just be sure to keep it chilled, as the filling is best served cold.

Freezing

Fluffernutter Pie freezes beautifully! Wrap the whole pie or individual slices in two layers of plastic wrap and one of foil, then freeze for up to a month. Thaw slices in the refrigerator overnight before enjoying. This is perfect for making ahead for potlucks or surprise guests.

Reheating

No need to reheat Fluffernutter Pie, as it’s meant to be served cold and creamy. If it’s been in the freezer, give it enough time to thaw in the fridge so the texture stays luscious. Avoid microwaving, as this could melt and break the filling.

FAQs

Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy?

Absolutely! Crunchy peanut butter adds delightful little nutty bits in every bite. Just know your filling will have a bit more texture, which many find to be a fun twist on traditional Fluffernutter Pie.

What’s the best way to soften cream cheese quickly?

Cut the cream cheese into cubes and let it sit at room temperature for about 15-20 minutes. If you’re short on time, you can microwave it in 10-second bursts, just until softened—just keep an eye on it so it doesn’t melt too much.

Can I make Fluffernutter Pie in advance for a party?

Definitely! Prep the pie the night before and let it chill overnight. On party day, all you need to do is decorate and serve. Fluffernutter Pie is a true make-ahead superstar.

Is it possible to make this pie nut-free?

If you’re baking for someone with peanut allergies, use a creamy sunflower seed butter in place of peanut butter and skip the chopped peanuts. The pie will still be delicious, with a similar texture and richness.

What’s the secret to super smooth filling?

The trick is making sure your cream cheese is completely softened before mixing and that you thoroughly blend it with the peanut butter. Scrape down the sides of the bowl as you go—this will guarantee a lush, smooth Fluffernutter Pie filling every time.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re feeding a crowd or just need a pick-me-up treat, Fluffernutter Pie is a joy to share—and even more fun to eat. Give it a whirl and let the creamy, nutty, marshmallow magic make your day. Don’t be surprised if it becomes a new family favorite!

Print